1

In order to understand different VPN technologies I tried to write down how a single HTTP packet could look like using each implementation.

SSH VPN

HTTP | TCP | IP | Ethernet ||| SSH | TCP | IP | Ethernet

OpenVPN bridged mode

HTTP | TCP | IP | Ethernet ||| OpenVPN | TLS | TCP | IP | Ethernet

OpenVPN routed mode

HTTP | TCP | IP ||| OpenVPN | TLS | TCP | IP | Ethernet

IPSec tunnel mode

HTTP | TCP | IP ||| IPSec Auth Header | IP | Ethernet

PPTP

HTTP | TCP | IP | PPP ||| GRE | IP | Ethernet

L2TP

HTTP | TCP | IP | PPP ||| L2TP | UDP | IP | Ethernet

It is based on information from different sources and I'd like to ask three questions:
1) Are the diagrams correct?
2) Are PPP and Ethernet interchangeable?
3) Is OpenVPN 'TCP over TCP' as implied by the diagrams above?

2
  • PPP and ethernet are two different layer-2 protocols. Either can be used to encapsulate upper-layer protocols. Ethernet is a broadcast protocol, but PPP (Point-to-Point Protocol) is not. Both have pros and cons.
    – Ron Maupin
    Nov 27, 2016 at 16:55
  • @RonMaupin which in the context of the question means that my diagrams can use either. Thank you for your answer!
    – user32354
    Nov 27, 2016 at 20:04

1 Answer 1

1

1) I would say yes, they are correct for some variants of these VPNs.

2) Ron Maupin already pointed out a difference. PPP is sometimes used to insert authentication like in PPPoE or with some proprietary IPsec extensions using IKEv1.

3) OpenVPN is best used with UDP because TCP over TCP is not a good idea. This article from Olaf Titz explains why. Usually you only use TCP over TCP when UDP isn't possible because some firewall on the way between the VPN gateways won't allow it.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy