6

I have a used switch with some SFP ports and some SFP modules installed, which I don't use.

All new switches come with little rubbery bungs that block up unused SFP ports, but since this old procurve was in use, those bungs are gone.

1) Do I need to protect the physical empty SFP port? What's a good way to do so?

Similarly, two of my ports have an SFP module installed, but I don't need to use them. They were used in the past and there are no smaller bungs to protect their LC port-holes.

2) Do I need to protect the one/two ports in a SFP module? If so, how?

3) Should I remove the unused SFPs from the switch and store them elsewhere?

SFP module with bung protecting LC ports. enter image description here

SFP module without protection enter image description here

  • 3
    A lot depends on how dusty your environment is. For my industrial work, I often tape up unused ether and SFP module sockets with masking tape; in nice filtered machine rooms I don't. But keep the optical paths covered, I use masking tape again, as I always lose the rubber stoppers. I keep the SFP modules in place, otherwise I lose those too. – jonathanjo Apr 24 at 12:23
  • 2
    In sort: YES. No matter how clean you think the place is, there will be dust. (or as in our last office, some jack*** will cut a hole through the wall, and leave it. they actually cut several, ran conduit, and reapplied fire guard -- in an ACTIVE DATA CENTER!) – Ricky Beam Apr 24 at 16:58
  • Sorry for the multi-part question, but they're all closely related and about unused SFP/ports. – Criggie Apr 24 at 22:14
10

Do I need to protect the physical empty SFP port? What's a good way to do so?

Empty SFP slots should be covered when not in use, so no dust is sucked up by the system fan - depending on how dusty the environment is, pressure of the fan etc, this isn't required at all times. Do make sure the slot is clean before inserting a module though.

You can use just about anything, even a piece of tape provided there's no sticky residue. Most RJ45 fillers fit pretty well.

Similarly, two of my ports have an SFP module installed, but I don't need to use them. They were used in the past and there are no smaller bungs to protect their LC port-holes.

You do need to protect unused LC jacks from dust. If some dust settles inside the connector it might be pushed to the end face when a connector is plugged. Dirt causes high attenuation including link loss and can be very hard to remove. Also, when the end face gets scratched you need replacement. If you remove unused SFPs and store them in a clean container that's fine as well. Don't forget about empty panel jacks, they're even harder to clean or replace.

Do I need to protect the one/two ports in a SFP module? If so, how?

You need to protect both, receive and transmit sides, from dirt.

Should I remove the unused SFPs from the switch and store them elsewhere?

You'd want to remove unused SFP modules. Leaving them idle still ages their electronics and optics (although modern SFPs have a pretty long service life) and saves energy (each watt amounts to 8.8 kWh per year).

Make sure you know (mark) where the transceiver belongs to, so you don't end up troubleshooting a failing link when the SFP simply isn't compatible.

  • 2
    8.8kWh wasted is an incredibly high when you think about it. This is the needed energy to drive 60km with a 1730kg Tesla Model 3. – Nakrule Apr 25 at 7:05
  • @Nakrule It does seem quite high, but the figure is over a year. 8800 Watt Hours over a year is almost exactly one watt-hour every hour, which means 1 Watt. sopto.com/learningcenter_learningcenter_176/… suggests 1.5-3.5 Watts per 10G SFP, so its surprisingly all in the same ballpark. There are a lot of hours in a year. – Criggie Apr 25 at 9:13
  • An average year has 365.25 * 24 = 8,766 hours. 1 W * 8,766 h = 8,766 Wh = 8.766 kWh. – Zac67 Apr 25 at 17:47
5

Cisco writes the following about the dust caps:

For optical SFP transceiver modules, before removing the dust plugs and making any optical connections, observe the following guidelines:

  • Always keep the protective dust plugs on the unplugged fiber-optic cable connectors and the transceiver optical bores until you are ready to make a connection.

  • Always inspect and clean the LC connector end-faces just before making any connections. See the Tip on this page for a pointer to a fiber-optic inspection and cleaning white paper.

Tip: For complete information on inspecting and cleaning fiber-optic connections, see the white-paper document at this URL:

https://www.cisco.com/c/en/us/support/docs/optical/synchronous-digital-hierarchy-sdh/51834-cleanfiber2.html

  • Always grasp the LC connector housing to plug or unplug a fiber-optic cable.

More info in the following link: https://www.cisco.com/c/en/us/td/docs/interfaces_modules/transceiver_modules/installation/note/78_15160.html

Also, as written by serverAdmin123, i would disconnect the transceiver and get some dust caps to keep them protected.

4

Do I need to protect the physical empty SFP port? What's a good way to do so?

Need to? Generally speaking no you don't need to do so. I have seen equipment used in construction trailers for years which have worked just fine when a SFP/GBIC is installed later.

However, I would recommend you do so. Why? Because there is the chance of causing a failure that could be more costly and/or time consuming than if you had put in a tiny amount of preventative work. Like many things, if you put a little more effort in when you have the opportunity, it will often save you (or someone else) a lot of time and/or frustration that could be avoided.

If you don't have something specific to the task, I personally like gaff/gaffer tape as it rips easily and tends to leave little to no residue when you remove it.

Do I need to protect the one/two ports in a SFP module? If so, how?

Again, need? No, but you should do so. If you don't have the caps to do so properly something as simple as a plastic bag or box that seals will avoid most of the potential problems. If something like that isn't handy, a small piece of the aforementioned gaffer tape will work in a pinch.

In any event, I always recommend getting and using a proper fiber cleaning kit whenever you make fiber connections. Always clean connectors and cables on both ends when making the connection. If you have it, some sort of fiber scope for inspections also helps.

I can't begin to count the times where a simple cleaning has stopped errors or low power issues on "problematic" fiber runs. Even with new equipment/cables that have never been used and have been capped, I often find that if you inspect them with a scope you will find traces of oil or residue from the factory present on the face of the fiber.

Let me say it again. Put in a little more effort when you have the opportunity and it will often save you (or others) time and/or frustration that can be avoided.

Should I remove the unused SFPs from the switch and store them elsewhere?

Let me ask, generally speaking, should you power off and/or unplug electronics you are not using? Same general answers apply.

First, electronics have a "life" expectancy. The longer they are in use, the more likely they will fail (excluding early failures often caused by defect). SFPs that are plugged in will be "in use" even if you connect no cable to them. While their MTBF (mean time between failure) may be significantly higher than the life of the equipment you are using them in, why tempt fate?

Second, it is a waste of power. While the power draw may be relatively tiny, it isn't to be overlooked. In data centers, there may be tight power/cooling budgets that any little bit helps. Or an organization may potentially have hundreds or thousands of SFPs that could be removed, multiplying that relatively tiny amount of power into something more significant (and costly). Finally, being green is good for everyone.

  • Excellent points. In the past I've removed ram from a FreeNAS server because it simply wasn't being used according to records. (96 GB, host was using ~12GB) – Criggie Apr 24 at 22:13
3

I think this is a somewhat broader question and i will put answer as much as simple. You need to protect Empty SFP module. You can purchase additional dust cap if it is required.

Generally most of electronic device has environmental requirements. If you can provide required environment device can have more durability.

I am confusing about your second question and third point is depend on environment. If you can provide better environment for transceivers than your server room. Definitely Answer is 'yes'. It will help to increase life time of transceiver.

Not only that I think it is good for any electronic device.

In addition to that follow device manual you can find many best practices which are recommended by manufacture.

2

While you should follow the manufacturer recommendations, I've seen dozens of SFP without dust caps in various states. Unfortunately not everyone you work with will be as diligent.

  • Sitting on benches/desks
  • Plugged into FC switches (Brocade dist., Cisco MCS, etc)
  • Hanging half out of sfp ports

I've seen similar treatment for LC cables, though they generally hang with the connector facing down which reduces the chance of dust settling on the optic.

Personally I've never seen this introduce faults and have seen far more issues with failed SFP (ie: not detected on the copper side) and Cisco IOS not accepting SFP (there used to be a bug that IOS would not allow the newly manufactured SFP hardware address). Keeping in mind my sample set is relatively small, though I've not heard of anyone mention this causing issues.

Yes you should definitely spend the 2 seconds to chase down the rubber caps and put them back on, but it seems highly unlikely that it will introduce issues into your environment if someone failed to do it.

  • I work with these devices every day, and I always see the SFPs (and QSFPs, CFPs, etc) just laying around. Never seen any issue either. We do, of course, clean them before using them again, though. If you aren't going to use a dust cap, definitely clean the SFP and the fiber before reconnecting. – Patrick Apr 24 at 15:32
1

I have worked in optic communications for over 10 years and have a lot of experience with dust, cleaning equipment, transceivers and fiber scopes. In my opinion it would make a lot of sense to disconnect the transceivers and store them in a safe place. First of all you will save energy, both in the switch and for the cooling system. It will keep switch temperature lower thus giving your switch more lifetime.

You won't need to cover the SFP cage's holes, there is only an electric connection in the back. If you change transceivers very often you might run into connectivity issues as especially cheap equipment does not support a whole lot of connection cycles, but we are still talking about hundreds of transceiver swaps.

As for the transceivers themselves I strongly recommend dust caps. (Same applies for the LC connectors on the fibers). And do not assume they are clean when you buy them. I have seen dirty connectors on brand new cables, even with expensive brands. Always clean and check before you connect.

Cleaning transceivers is a different story. It MIGHT make sense but depends on the optics in use. There are usually 2 elements called TOSA and ROSA for transmitting and receiving. Some of them have accessable lenses you can clean with the right cleaning equipment (please no compressed air!) while others have a smaller hole in the middle and cleaning attempts will only make things worse. Unfortunately most transceiver vendors won't be able to tell you what they have in their transceivers, as most of them are OEM products anyway. The best way to check is using an electronic fiber scope.

Or - which works most of the time - you take the less professional approach and just take the chances and give it a try. Will also work for 80%+ ;-) But I would not recommend this for dusty environments where I have seen a nearly 100% failure rate on optical connections when leaving them open for some time. Hope this helps.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.